The Ultimate Lash Transformation: A Deep Dive Review of the Tarte Tubing Mascara

If you are anything like me, your quest for the “Holy Grail” mascara has been a lifelong journey filled with trial, error, and unfortunately, a lot of raccoon eyes. We have all been there: you apply a mascara at 8:00 AM that looks stunning, only to catch a glimpse of yourself in the rearview mirror at 2:00 PM and realize you have flakes on your cheeks and smudges under your lower lash line.

Enter the world of tubing technology. While traditional mascaras paint your lashes with pigment, tubing mascaras wrap them in polymer “sleeves.” Today, we are going to dive deep into one of the most talked-about contenders in this category. We are putting the Tarte Tubing Mascara to the ultimate test.

In this extensive review, we will cover everything you need to know: the science behind the formula, a deep dive into the ingredients, a full day wear-test, and exactly how it stacks up against the competition. If you are tired of scrubbing at your eyes every night and waking up with dark circles, keep reading. This might just be the game-changer you have been waiting for.

What Exactly is the Tarte Tartelette Tubing Mascara?

Before we get into the nitty-gritty of performance, let’s establish what this product claims to be. The Tarte Tubing Mascara (officially named the Tartelette Tubing Mascara) launched with massive hype, promising the look of lash extensions without the glue, damage, or expensive salon visits.

Tarte markets this as their first-ever tubing formula. If you are familiar with the brand, you know they are famous for their “Lights, Camera, Lashes” mascara, which is a cult classic traditional formula. However, the Tarte Tubing Mascara is a completely different beast. It promises 24-hour flake-free wear, smudge-proof longevity, and sweat-proof performance.

The core promise here is “micro-tubing technology.” Instead of weighing the lashes down with heavy waxes that can melt with your body heat or natural oils, this formula wraps each individual lash in a lightweight, lengthening tube. The result? Extreme length and definition that is supposed to withstand the rigors of daily life.

The Science of “Tubing”: Why It Matters

To understand why the Tarte Tubing Mascara is creating such a buzz, we have to look at the mechanics of mascara. Traditional oil-based or wax-based mascaras work by coating the lash. Think of it like painting a wall. The paint sits on top. If you touch the wall while it’s wet—or if the room gets too hot and humid—the paint can smear. Similarly, oils from your skin can break down traditional mascara, causing it to migrate under your eyes.

Tubing mascara is different. It uses polymers that shrink-wrap around the lash. Once these tubes dry, they are essentially smudge-proof because they aren’t dissolved by oil. They are water-resistant but not waterproof in the traditional sense. This means you can cry, sweat, or have oily eyelids, and the Tarte Tubing Mascara shouldn’t budge.

However, the real magic happens during removal, which we will discuss in detail later. Because the tubes are water-resistant but respond to warm water and pressure, they slide off in whole pieces, eliminating the need for harsh makeup removers.

Packaging and First Impressions

Tarte is known for cute, aesthetic packaging, and the Tarte Tubing Mascara is no exception. It comes in a sleek, metallic lilac tube with gold lettering. It feels weighted and luxurious in the hand, not cheap or flimsy.

When you unscrew the cap, you are introduced to the wand. This is a crucial part of the review because a formula is only as good as the applicator that delivers it. The Tarte Tubing Mascara features a molded plastic brush with hundreds of tiny bristles. The wand is straight and slightly tapered at the tip.

I generally prefer plastic bristles over natural fiber brushes for tubing formulas because they are better at combing through the lashes and separating them. This prevents the “clumpy spider leg” look that can happen if multiple lashes get stuck inside a single polymer tube. The bristles on this wand are sharp enough to comb through but soft enough not to scratch the waterline.

Ingredient Spotlight: Lash-Loving Care

One of the reasons I was drawn to review the Tarte Tubing Mascara is Tarte’s commitment to “high-performance naturals.” They generally formulate without parabens, mineral oil, phthalates, triclosan, sodium lauryl sulfate, and gluten. But what is in it?

Here is a breakdown of the star ingredients that make this formula unique:

1. Shea Butter: We usually see this in body lotions, but in mascara? Yes. Shea butter conditions the lashes. Many waterproof mascaras dry out the lashes, leading to brittleness and breakage over time. The inclusion of shea butter ensures that while the Tarte Tubing Mascara is lengthening your lashes, it is also keeping them soft and flexible.
2. Castor Oil: This is a holy grail ingredient in the natural beauty world for hair growth. While Tarte doesn’t claim this mascara grows your lashes, castor oil is known to moisturize and strengthen hair follicles. Using a product daily that contains castor oil is a proactive step toward lash health.
3. Carnauba Wax: This is a plant-based wax that allows for smooth application. It ensures the formula glides on without dragging or pulling at the delicate lash hairs. It also helps lengthen and volumize by building up the structure of the “tube.”

Knowing that the Tarte Tubing Mascara is packed with conditioning agents makes me feel better about wearing it every single day. It feels like a hybrid between makeup and lash care.

The Application Process: Step-by-Step

How do you get the best results with the Tarte Tubing Mascara? Unlike traditional mascaras where you might wiggle the wand at the base to build volume, tubing mascaras require a slightly different technique to maximize length.

Step 1: The Curl Always start with clean, dry lashes. Use an eyelash curler to give your lashes a lift. Because tubing formulas can be wet, curling beforehand is essential to lock in that upward shape before the tubes set.

Step 2: The First Coat Pull the wand out of the tube (do not pump it, as this pushes air in and dries out the formula). Place the brush at the very base of your lashes. Instead of a heavy zig-zag motion, pull the wand straight up through the tips. The Tarte Tubing Mascara is designed to grab every lash. On the first pass, you will notice immediate separation and tinting.

Step 3: Building Length This is where the magic happens. While the first coat is still slightly tacky, apply a second coat focusing strictly on the tips of the lashes. The polymers in the Tarte Tubing Mascara adhere to the ends of your lashes, acting almost like magnetic extensions. You can visibly see your lashes growing longer with each stroke.

Step 4: The Lower Lashes Because this formula is smudge-proof, it is perfect for lower lashes. Use the tapered tip of the wand to gently coat the bottom lashes. You don’t have to worry about looking like a panda an hour later.

Performance: The 12-Hour Wear Test

To give you an honest review, I put the Tarte Tubing Mascara through a rigorous 12-hour day. Here is how it held up.

8:00 AM – Application The application was smooth. The formula is on the wetter side, which gave me plenty of time to work with it before it set. I managed to get incredible length—my lashes looked like falsies, specifically the “wispy” kind. It didn’t provide massive thickness or volume at the base, but the length was undeniable.

12:00 PM – The Lunch Check Usually, by lunch, my oily eyelids have started to break down my mascara, leaving black dots on my brow bone. With the Tarte Tubing Mascara, my eyes looked exactly the same as they did at 8:00 AM. The curl had dropped slightly (which is common with heavier tubing formulas), but the pigment was pitch black and crisp.

4:00 PM – The Slump I went for a brisk walk, and it was a bit humid. This is the danger zone for most mascaras. I checked the mirror expecting to see smudging under my eyes. Nothing. Absolutely zero transfer. This confirms that the Tarte Tubing Mascara is indeed sweat-resistant and oil-resistant.

8:00 PM – End of Day After 12 hours of wear, including screen time, rubbing my eyes (accidentally), and dealing with humidity, the mascara was still intact. There was no flaking on my cheeks. This is a massive win. Traditional volumizing mascaras often flake once they dry out completely, but the polymer tubes kept the pigment contained.

Comparison: Tarte Tubing Mascara vs. The Competition

The tubing mascara market has exploded recently. How does the Tarte Tubing Mascara compare to other heavy hitters?

Tarte Tubing Mascara vs. Thrive Causemetics Liquid Lash Extensions

Thrive Causemetics essentially put tubing mascara on the map for the modern consumer.

• Formula: Thrive is drier and sets faster. Tarte is wetter and more conditioning.
• Look: Thrive gives a slightly thicker, bolder look. Tarte gives a cleaner, more separated, and feathery look.
• Removal: Both remove easily with water, but I found the Tarte tubes broke down slightly faster.
• Verdict: If you want drama and thickness, go Thrive. If you want separation, length, and healthy ingredients, the Tarte Tubing Mascara wins.

Tarte Tubing Mascara vs. Blinc Mascara

Blinc is the OG tubing mascara.

• Formula: Blinc is very thin and can sometimes lack “oomph.”
• Performance: Tarte outperforms Blinc significantly in the drama department. Blinc is great for a “no-makeup” makeup look, but Tarte actually makes your lashes look extended.
• Verdict: Tarte is the clear winner for modern makeup preferences.

Tarte Tubing Mascara vs. Tarte Lights, Camera, Lashes

How does it compare to its sister product?

• Type: Lights, Camera, Lashes is a traditional wax-based mascara.
• Volume: The traditional formula gives much more volume at the root.
• Longevity: The Tarte Tubing Mascara destroys the original in terms of longevity. Lights, Camera, Lashes will smudge if you have oily lids; the Tubing version will not.

The Removal Process: Is it Really That Easy?

The most intimidating part of tubing mascara for newbies is the removal. It feels counter-intuitive. You do not use makeup remover, micellar water, or cleansing balms. In fact, using those products often results in a mess because they just slide the tubes around without breaking the seal.

To remove the Tarte Tubing Mascara, follow these steps:

1. Splash your face with warm water. The water must be warm (not cold) to help expand the tubes.
2. Apply gentle pressure with your fingertips or a washcloth.
3. Gently stroke your lashes downward.

This is the part that freaks people out: you will see little black spider-looking things in the sink. Those are not your lashes. Those are the polymer tubes sliding off your lashes. Your natural lashes remain intact on your eyelids.

I found the Tarte Tubing Mascara to be one of the easiest removals I have ever experienced. It required zero rubbing or tugging. This is a huge benefit for anti-aging, as tugging at the delicate eye area is a leading cause of premature wrinkles. It also ensures you don’t go to bed with leftover mascara residue, which can cause eye infections.

Who is the Tarte Tubing Mascara For?

After testing this product extensively, I have identified exactly who will benefit most from this formula.

1. People with Oily Eyelids If every mascara you buy ends up under your eyes within two hours, you have oily lids. The Tarte Tubing Mascara is the solution. Oil cannot penetrate the polymer tube.

2. Contact Lens Wearers Flaking mascara is a nightmare for contact lens wearers. A flake getting trapped under a lens is painful. Because this formula does not flake, it is safe and comfortable for sensitive eyes and contact lens users.

3. People with Straight or Short Lashes The extension-like properties of this formula provide significant length. While it holds a curl decently, its main strength is adding millimeters to the tips of the lashes.

4. The “Clean Girl” Aesthetic If you like the look of separated, long, natural-looking lashes rather than clumpy, thick rock-star lashes, this is for you. It defines the eyes beautifully without looking heavy.

Pros and Cons Breakdown

To summarize my experience with the Tarte Tubing Mascara, let’s look at the pros and cons.

Pros:

• Incredible Length: It genuinely mimics the look of lash extensions.
• Zero Smudging: It is virtually impossible to smudge this once it sets.
• Easy Removal: No makeup remover required, just warm water.
• Lash Health: Contains shea butter and castor oil to condition lashes.
• Clean Ingredients: Free from harsh chemicals often found in drugstore mascaras.
• Cruelty-Free and Vegan: Tarte is a brand that aligns with ethical beauty standards.

Cons:

• Lack of Volume: If you crave thick, chunky lashes, you might find this formula too thin. It prioritizes length over volume.
• Wet Formula: It can be a bit wet upon opening, requiring a steady hand to avoid getting it on your eyelids during application.
• Price: It is a prestige product with a higher price point than drugstore alternatives (though I argue the quality justifies the cost).

Tips and Tricks for Maximum Volume

Since the one drawback of the Tarte Tubing Mascara is a lack of volume, here are my top tips to hack the formula for a fuller look:

• Tightline First: Use a black waterproof eyeliner to fill in the upper waterline before applying the mascara. This creates the illusion of a thicker lash base.
• Layer with a Primer: Tarte sells a lash primer (Opening Act), but you can use any white lash primer. Apply the primer to build bulk, let it dry, and then encase it in the tubing mascara. This gives you the volume of a primer with the smudge-proof benefits of a tube.
• The “Blink” Method: When applying, blink down onto the wand as you pull it through. This forces the lashes deep into the bristles, ensuring they are coated from all angles for maximum thickness.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Q: Is Tarte Tubing Mascara waterproof? A: It is water-resistant, meaning it can withstand rain, sweat, and tears. However, it is removed with warm water and pressure, so it is not “waterproof” in the sense that you can go swimming underwater with it for hours.

Q: Does it hold a curl? A: It holds a curl well for a tubing mascara. Because the formula contains conditioning oils, it can be slightly heavier than alcohol-based waterproof mascaras. I recommend curling your lashes aggressively before application.

Q: How long does a tube last? A: Due to the nature of tubing formulas, you should replace the Tarte Tubing Mascara every 3 to 4 months. If you pump the wand, it will dry out faster.

Q: Can I use this on bottom lashes? A: Absolutely. It is arguably the best type of mascara for bottom lashes because it will not transfer onto your concealer or under-eye area.

Q: Does it irritate sensitive eyes? A: In my experience, no. It is ophthalmologist-tested and safe for contact lens wearers. The absence of flaking prevents particles from falling into the eye throughout the day.

Final Verdict: Is the Tarte Tubing Mascara Worth the Hype?

After a comprehensive analysis, over 2000 words of breakdown, and a full day of wear, the verdict is in. The Tarte Tubing Mascara is a resounding success, provided you know what you are buying.

If you are looking for a mascara that will give you the thickest, blackest, most voluminous lashes visible from space, this might not be your number one pick. You might be better off with a traditional wax formula.

However, if you are looking for length, definition, separation, and bulletproof longevity, the Tarte Tubing Mascara is a superstar product. It solves the biggest complaints women have about mascara: smudging and difficult removal. It takes the technology of tubing mascaras and elevates it with nourishing ingredients like castor oil and shea butter, ensuring that your lashes aren’t just painted, but pampered.

For anyone who struggles with raccoon eyes by midday, or for anyone who hates the nightly ritual of scrubbing their eyes with oil cleansers, this product is a must-have. It simplifies your beauty routine while delivering high-impact results.

The Tarte Tubing Mascara has earned its spot in my daily rotation. It delivers on its promise of “lash extensions in a tube,” and for that reason, it is well worth the investment. Whether you are heading to the office, the gym, or a night out, you can trust that this mascara will stay exactly where you put it until you decide to take it off. And in the world of beauty, that reliability is priceless.

---

Disclaimer: This review is based on personal testing and research of the ingredients and product claims. Individual results may vary depending on lash type and skin oiliness.

Check out Tarte Tartelette Tubing Mascara on Amazon.

See more Makeup product reviews here.

*As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.