The Ultimate Review: Is the Tarte Sex Kitten Liquid Liner the Purr-fect Choice for You?

Finding the holy grail of eyeliners is a journey almost every makeup enthusiast has embarked upon. We have all been there: the smudged wings by midday, the formulas that crack and flake, or the felt tips that dry out after three uses. The search for a liner that is pitch black, easy to apply, and genuinely waterproof is endless.

In the crowded market of high-end cosmetics, Tarte Cosmetics has always stood out for its commitment to “high-performance naturals.” But does their Tarte Liquid Liner—specifically the Sex Kitten edition—live up to the hype?

In this extensive review, we are going to deep-dive into every single aspect of the Tarte Sex Kitten Liquid Liner. From the packaging and ingredients to a stress-test of its longevity and a comparison with its biggest rivals, we will cover it all. If you have been on the fence about adding this Tarte Liquid Liner to your cart, read on.

Part 1: First Impressions and Brand Philosophy

The Tarte Cosmetics Legacy

To understand the value of this product, we first have to look at the brand behind it. Tarte Cosmetics has built a massive following based on a specific niche: cruelty-free, eco-chic beauty that actually performs. They are famous for their Amazonian Clay blushes and Shape Tape concealer, but their eye products are often the unsung heroes of the line.

When you buy a Tarte Liquid Liner, you are buying into the promise that you don’t have to sacrifice ingredient safety for performance. Tarte is known for leaving out the “bad stuff”—parabens, mineral oil, phthalates, and gluten. For those with sensitive eyes or contact lens wearers, this brand philosophy is often the deciding factor.

Unboxing the Sex Kitten

The Tarte Sex Kitten Liquid Liner is, without a doubt, one of the cutest products on the vanity table. Tarte knows how to do packaging. The tube itself is sleek, but the topper is the conversation starter: a small, adorable cat head adorns the cap.

While some might find this “kitschy,” it serves a functional purpose which we will discuss later in the ergonomics section. The packaging feels lightweight yet sturdy. It’s travel-friendly and easy to spot in a cluttered makeup bag thanks to that distinct cat silhouette.

The Claims

Before we test the product, let’s look at what Tarte promises with this specific Tarte Liquid Liner:

Triple-Black Pigment: An intense black payoff.
Waterproof & Smudge-proof: A 12-hour wear time that withstands sweat and humidity.
Precision Tip: A superfine felt tip designed for razor-sharp wings.
Vegan & Cruelty-Free: Safe for animals and safe for you.

Part 2: The Design and Applicator

The most critical component of any liquid eyeliner is the applicator. You can have the best formula in the world, but if the tool used to apply it is subpar, the product fails.

The Felt Tip vs. Brush Tip Debate

In the world of liquid liners, there are two camps: felt tip and brush tip.

Brush Tips are made of individual synthetic bristles. They are flexible and move with the curve of the eye.
Felt Tips are solid, marker-like tips. They offer more stability and control.

The Sex Kitten Tarte Liquid Liner features a felt tip. However, it is not the stiff, hard marker tip you might be used to from drugstore brands. This felt tip is elongated, tapered, and remarkably flexible.

Precision and Control

Because the tip is so fine, it allows for extreme precision. If you are someone who struggles with shaky hands, this type of Tarte Liquid Liner is often superior to a brush tip. The slight resistance of the felt tip against the skin gives you more control over the line. You can stamp the liner right into the lash line for a subtle definition or drag it out for a dramatic cat eye.

The “Sex Kitten” moniker is appropriate here because this tip is specifically engineered for the “cat eye” look. The very tip of the applicator is sharp enough to create that elusive, razor-thin tail of the wing that tapers off into nothingness.

Ergonomics

Remember the cat head on the cap? It isn’t just for show. The cap provides a decent grip, and the tube is short enough to get close to a mirror without the handle hitting the glass. The weight balance is centered, preventing the liner from feeling top-heavy in your hand.

Part 3: The Formula and Ingredients

This is where the Tarte Liquid Liner attempts to separate itself from the competition. Most waterproof liners are heavy on chemicals to seal the pigment. Tarte takes a different approach.

Key Ingredients

Water & Acrylates Copolymer: The base of the liner that creates the film-forming layer, ensuring the liner dries down and stays put.
Castor Oil: This is a standout ingredient. Castor oil is famously known for promoting hair health and moisture. By including this in the formula, Tarte ensures that the liner glides over the delicate eyelid skin without dragging or skipping. It also conditions the lash line.
Glycerin: A humectant that helps hydrate. This prevents the liner from drying out into a cracked, flaky mess on the eyelid.
Black 2 (CI 77266): The source of the pigment. Tarte uses high-grade pigment to ensure opacity in a single swipe.

The “Clean” Beauty Aspect

For users with sensitive eyes, the ingredient list is paramount. Many liquid liners cause stinging or irritation, especially if they flake into the eye during the day. This Tarte Liquid Liner is ophthalmologist-tested. It is formulated without the “icky” additives that often cause allergic reactions. If you have had trouble with eyes watering immediately after applying liner in the past, the Sex Kitten formula is a safer bet.

Part 4: The Performance Test

Now, let’s get into the nitty-gritty: how does this Tarte Liquid Liner actually perform in real-world scenarios?

Pigmentation and Opacity

The claim of “Triple Black” pigment is bold. Upon the first swatch, the liner deposits a rich, deep ink. It is not a watery grey or a translucent black; it is a solid midnight black.

One of the biggest frustrations with felt tip liners is that the ink flow can be inconsistent. Sometimes the tip dries out halfway through doing your second eye. In testing the Sex Kitten Tarte Liquid Liner, the ink flow system seems robust. The product flows to the tip consistently, provided you store it specifically (more on that in the Tips section). You rarely have to go over the same line twice to get full opacity, which reduces the risk of the liner getting thick and chunky.

The Finish

This liner dries down to a semi-matte finish. It is not dead flat matte (which can sometimes look chalky), but it isn’t glossy or vinyl-like either. It mimics the natural texture of skin, which makes it look very high-end. This finish is versatile; it works for a natural “no-makeup” makeup look just as well as it does for a full glam evening look.

Drying Time

Speed is of the essence when applying makeup in the morning. A wet liner is a disaster waiting to happen—one blink and you have a black arc on your upper lid. The Sex Kitten Tarte Liquid Liner dries relatively fast. It sets within roughly 10 to 15 seconds. This is the “Goldilocks” zone: it dries fast enough to prevent transfer, but slow enough that you have a few seconds to correct a mistake if your hand slips.

The Smudge Test

Once this liner sets, it sets. Rubbing your hand across a swatch of dried liner results in zero movement. It does not smear. This is crucial for contact lens wearers or people who have a habit of touching their eyes.

The Water Test

Tarte claims this is waterproof. Is it? If you get caught in the rain or cry during a sad movie, the liner will hold. It is highly water-resistant. However, it is not “cement.” If you submerge your face in a pool and rub your eyes, it will come off. But for standard daily humidity, sweat, and tears, the Tarte Liquid Liner holds its ground admirably.

Part 5: Suitability for Different Eye Shapes

Not all liners work for all eyes. The anatomy of your eyelid dictates how a product wears.

For Hooded Eyes

Hooded eyes are the ultimate nemesis of liquid eyeliner. Because the skin of the upper brow bone folds over the lash line, transfer is a constant issue. The Tarte Liquid Liner is an excellent choice for hooded eyes because of its quick-drying nature and transfer-proof formula. Once it dries, it does not tack up or stick to the upper lid. The fine tip also allows those with hooded eyes to create a very thin line that doesn’t overwhelm the small amount of visible lid space.

For Oily Lids

If you have oily eyelids, you know that oil breaks down makeup faster than water. The sebum produced by your skin acts as a natural makeup remover. This liner holds up surprisingly well on oily lids, likely due to the acrylates copolymer which forms a flexible shield. However, for those with extremely oily lids, pairing this Tarte Liquid Liner with an eyeshadow primer is still recommended for ensuring the 12-hour wear claim.

For Mature Eyes

Mature eyelids often have more texture and fine lines (crepe-y skin). Liquid liners can sometimes “bleed” or “feather” into these fine lines. Because the formula contains castor oil and glycerin, it has a slight elasticity to it. It moves with the skin rather than cracking against it. The felt tip is soft enough not to drag or tug on delicate, mature skin, making it a friendly option for older demographics.

Part 6: Comparison with Competitors

To truly evaluate the Sex Kitten Tarte Liquid Liner, we must stack it up against the industry titans.

Tarte Sex Kitten vs. Stila Stay All Day

The Tip: Stila also uses a felt tip, but Stila’s tip is slightly shorter and stiffer. Tarte’s is longer and more flexible.
The Formula: Stila is often cited as the longest-wearing liner on the market. While Tarte wears beautifully, Stila might have a slight edge in extreme endurance (like swimming). However, Tarte feels less drying on the lids over time.
The Blackness: Tarte’s Sex Kitten often appears slightly blacker and less shiny than Stila’s standard black.

Tarte Sex Kitten vs. KVD Beauty Tattoo Liner

The Tip: This is the biggest difference. KVD uses a brush tip (bristles). The Tarte Liquid Liner uses a felt tip. If you prefer the “marker” feel, Tarte is better. If you prefer the “paintbrush” feel, KVD is better.
The Ink Flow: KVD is notorious for drying out or clogging due to eyeshadow buildup. The felt tip on the Tarte liner seems more resistant to clogging, perhaps because the felt material filters the ink differently.

Tarte Sex Kitten vs. Tarte Maneater Liquid Liner

The Brand Siblings: Tarte also makes the “Maneater” liner. What’s the difference?
The Form: Maneater generally has a brush tip, while Sex Kitten has the felt tip.
The Function: Sex Kitten is marketed more towards the “cat eye” specifically, focusing on precision. Maneater is marketed for bold, thick lines. If you want detail work, stick with the Sex Kitten Tarte Liquid Liner.

Part 7: Pros and Cons Breakdown

Let’s summarize the findings into a clear list of pros and cons to help you make a quick decision.

The Pros

Ease of Use: The elongated felt tip makes creating a wing easier for beginners than almost any other tool.
Ingredient Integrity: Vegan, cruelty-free, and formulated with castor oil. It’s safer for sensitive eyes.
Pigmentation: Truly black. No need for layering.
Packaging: Cute, distinct, and ergonomic.
Longevity: Lasts through a standard work day and gym session without smudging.
Brand Trust: Tarte is a reliable brand with consistent quality control.

The Cons

Felt Tip Durability: Like all felt tips, the very point can fray slightly after months of heavy use, losing that razor-sharp precision.
Volume: The tube is small. Daily users may find they run out of product faster than with a gel pot liner.
Price Point: It is a prestige product with a prestige price tag. It is significantly more expensive than drugstore dupes like NYX.
Waterproof Limit: It is water-resistant, but heavy friction combined with water will remove it.

Part 8: How to Apply for the Perfect Wing

To get the most out of your Tarte Liquid Liner, technique matters. Here is a step-by-step guide to nailing the Sex Kitten look using this specific tool.

Step 1: Prep the Lid Ensure your eyelid is clean. If you have oily lids, apply a small amount of eyeshadow primer or a dusting of translucent powder. This gives the liner something to grip onto.

Step 2: Map the Angle Look straight into the mirror. Do not pull or stretch your skin (this causes the wing to warp when you let go). Align the tip of the Tarte Liquid Liner with your lower lash line and imagine a line extending up toward the tail of your brow. Draw a small dot or dash where you want the wing to end.

Step 3: Connect the Tail Place the felt tip at the dot you created and draw a diagonal line down toward your upper lash line. The flexibility of the Sex Kitten tip makes this swoop very natural.

Step 4: Line the Lid Starting from the inner corner of your eye, use small, stamping motions to line close to the lashes. As you reach the middle of the eye, begin to thicken the line slightly.

Step 5: Fill in the Triangle Connect the line on your lid to the diagonal wing you created. You should have a small empty triangle. Use the side of the felt tip (not just the point) to color it in quickly.

Step 6: Refine If the tail isn’t sharp enough, use the very finest point of the Tarte Liquid Liner to drag the tail out a millimeter further. If you made a mistake, wait for it to dry and use a Q-tip dipped in micellar water to clean up the edge.

Part 9: Maintenance and Storage Tips

Many users complain that their liquid liners dry out too fast. Often, this is not a product fault but a storage error. Here is how to extend the life of your Tarte Liquid Liner.

Store It Upside Down: Gravity is your friend. Store the liner with the cat-head cap facing down. This keeps the ink saturated at the tip, so it is ready to go the moment you open it.
Clean the Tip: If you apply liner over glittery eyeshadow, the felt tip can get clogged with shimmer particles. Gently wipe the tip on a clean tissue after use to remove eyeshadow debris.
Cap it Tight: Listen for the “click.” If the cap is not fully engaged, the alcohol in the formula will evaporate, and the liner will dry out overnight.

Part 10: FAQ: Common Questions About the Tarte Liquid Liner

Q: Is the Tarte Sex Kitten Liner oil-free? A: While it is formulated without mineral oil, it does contain Castor Oil. However, this oil is used for conditioning and generally does not cause the liner to break down like mineral oils do.

Q: Can I use this on my waterline? A: Liquid liners are generally not recommended for the waterline (the wet rim of the eye). The fluid can bleed into the eye and cause irritation. For the waterline, stick to a pencil kohl liner and use the Tarte Liquid Liner for the upper lash line only.

Q: Is this product safe for contact lens wearers? A: Yes. Because it does not flake, there is a very low risk of particles getting trapped under your contact lens. It is also ophthalmologist-tested.

Q: How do I remove it? A: Despite being waterproof, it removes easily with an oil-based cleanser or a bi-phase makeup remover. Micellar water may take a bit more rubbing, so an oil balm is recommended to dissolve it gently without tugging.

Q: Is it really vegan? A: Yes, Tarte lists the Sex Kitten Liquid Liner as 100% vegan. It contains no animal-derived ingredients and is not tested on animals.

Part 11: The Verdict

After thoroughly analyzing the packaging, ingredients, performance, and value, we can deliver a final verdict on the Tarte Sex Kitten Liquid Liner.

This product is a standout winner for a specific type of makeup user. It is arguably one of the best choices on the market for beginners and those who prioritize clean beauty. The ease of use provided by the high-quality felt tip lowers the barrier to entry for the difficult “cat eye” look. You don’t need to be a professional makeup artist to get a sharp wing with this tool.

While it carries a premium price tag, the inclusion of lash-loving ingredients like Castor Oil and the exclusion of harsh chemicals adds value that drugstore dupes simply cannot match. You aren’t just paying for a black line; you are paying for a formula that respects the health of your eyes and eyelids.

If you are looking for a liner that is intensely black, stays put all day, and looks adorable on your vanity, the Tarte Liquid Liner (Sex Kitten Edition) is an investment worth making. It bridges the gap between high-performance artistry and everyday wearability.

Rating:

Pigmentation: 5/5
Longevity: 4.5/5
Ease of Application: 5/5
Packaging: 5/5
Value for Money: 4/5

Final Score: 4.7/5

Whether you are heading to the office, the gym, or a night out, the Tarte Sex Kitten Liquid Liner is a trusty companion that ensures your eyes remain the center of attention. If you have been disappointed by dry, grey, or flaky liners in the past, it is time to switch to a product that treats your lashes right while making them look fierce.

So, are you ready to channel your inner Sex Kitten? This Tarte Liquid Liner might just be the tool you need to sharpen your look and your confidence.

Ready for More Beauty Insights?

If you found this review helpful, you might also be interested in our deep dives into other Tarte best-sellers or our guide on “Top 10 Vegan Makeup Brands You Need to Know.” Let us know in the comments: are you Team Felt Tip or Team Brush Tip? And have you tried the Sex Kitten liner yet?

Disclaimer: This review is based on independent analysis and ingredient research. Always patch test new cosmetics if you have highly sensitive skin.

Check out Tarte Sex Kitten Liquid Liner on Amazon.

See more Makeup product reviews here.

*As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.

Specs

Pros

Cons

Table of Contents